The Court of Appeal’s recent decision in DSG Retail Limited v The Information Commissioner [2026] widens the scope of a data controller’s duty to guard against the risk that personal data will be subject to unauthorised or unlawful processing by a third party.
For the purposes of determining the scope of a data controller’s security obligations, data will now constitute ‘personal data’ if it is capable of directly or indirectly, when combined with other information, identifying an individual in the data controller’s hands. Accordingly, data controllers are required to guard against the risk that data which relates to individuals who can be identified by the data controller will be subject to unauthorised or unlawful processing by a third party, even if that third party cannot identify those individuals.
This case stems from a cyber-attack on DSG Retail Limited (DSG), a national retailer operating stores at the time including Currys PC World and Dixons Travel. The attacker had installed malware on 5,390 tills at DSG retail stores, collecting the details of 5.6 million payment cards and the personal information of 14 million people over a nine-month period from July 2017 until April 2018, when the attack was eventually detected.
The Information Commission’s Office (ICO) investigated the cyber-attack, and found that DSG, as data controller for the relevant information, had poor data security arrangements and failed to take adequate steps to protect personal data, meaning that it had breached the Data Protection Act 1998.
The ICO concluded that the cyber-attack and unauthorised access to personal data that it entailed would “significantly affect individuals’ privacy, leaving affected customers vulnerable to financial theft and identity fraud”, and cause distress to individuals. Accordingly, the ICO issued DSG with a monetary penalty of £500,000, the maximum available fine under the act.
DSG appealed to the First-tier Tribunal , contending that certain data that had been accessed did not constitute personal data in the hands of the attackers. Specifically, DSG submitted that the majority of payment cards involved in the attack were protected by the chip-and-pin system, and accordingly the attackers had only obtained the 16-digit card number and expiry date, but not the cardholder’s name. DSG argued that these details did not constitute personal data in the hands of the attacker, as the cardholder could not be identified.
The First-tier Tribunal rejected this contention, holding that the data constituted personal data in the hands of DSG, irrespective of whether this would be the case from the perspective of a third party. Accordingly, DSG was under an obligation to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to protect that data. The First-tier Tribunal upheld the monetary penalty notice issued by the ICO, but reduced the value of the penalty to £250,000.
DSG appealed this decision to the Upper Tribunal, which found in its favour. The Upper Tribunal considered whether the card number and expiry date constituted personal data in the hands of the attacker, and concluded that “the question of whether third-party acquisition of the EMV data involved personal data had to be analysed from the perspective of the third party”. Accordingly, the data in question did not constitute personal data as it could not be used by the attackers to identify individuals. DSG, as data controller, was therefore not under a duty to take appropriate technical and organisational measures to protect against the accidental loss, destruction of, or damage to that data.
The ICO appealed the Upper Tribunal’s decision to the Court of Appeal, which has overturned the decision, holding that for the purposes of determining the scope of a data controller’s security obligations, the pertinent question is whether the information is personal data in the hands of the data controller – in this instance DSG. Accordingly, if the data is ‘personal’ from the perspective of the data controller, it will be unnecessary to pose the further question of whether they are personal data ‘in the hands of’ or ‘from the perspective’ of any other person.
Having clarified the relevant point of law, the Court of Appeal remitted the matter to the First-tier Tribunal for its application to the facts of the DSG cyber-attack. However, instead of re-running the substantive hearing before the First-tier Tribunal, the ICO and DSG have reached an agreement to settle the proceedings whereby DSG will pay £200,000 of the monetary penalty imposed.
The decision of the Court of Appeal has important ramifications for data controllers. They have a protective duty to safeguard all personal data that they hold from which they can identify individuals, even where cyber-attackers who might theoretically obtain that data cannot themselves identify the individuals concerned.
The Court of Appeal’s judgment makes the point that, whilst this may impose more burdensome obligations on data controllers, the exercise that they will now have to undertake is not fundamentally different following its judgment. Data controllers would still be required, following either the decision of the Upper Tribunal or Court of Appeal, to assess the risk of ‘jigsaw’ identification with regard to any data that relates to an individual but does not contain the means of identification. Accordingly, a data controller in possession of information amounting to personal data ‘in its hands’ will only be able to firmly evaluate its security duty if it has first conducted a thorough analysis of that issue.
The Court of Appeal’s decision also has implications for data breach damages claims, which often arise in the context of cyber-attacks where data is accessed by the attackers without the data controller’s authorisation.
Claimants pursuing such claims are first required to establish that a business has infringed UK data protection law, pursuant to Article 82 UK GDPR. In claims relating to cyber-attacks, claimants often point to breaches such as unauthorised processing of personal data, failure to implement appropriate data security measures or non-compliance with the principles of data processing.
One implication of the Court of Appeal’s decision is that claimants may now find it easier to establish an infringement, as businesses subject to cyber-attacks are required to protect a wider range of data, including data that would not previously have amounted to personal data in the hands of the attackers. This could include stolen payment card information that does not include the names of the cardholders, as in the case of DSG, or details from customer databases or pseudonymised data, for example.
However, data controllers can be reassured that claimants pursuing such claims will still be required to establish that they have suffered compensable damage as a result of any infringement of data protection law (Lloyd v Google). This damage may be material financial loss, or non-material loss, such as distress, anxiety or loss of control over personal data.
Accordingly, while the Court of Appeal’s decision in DSG may broaden the circumstances in which claimants can establish an underlying infringement of UK data protection law following a cyber-attack, claimants are still required to demonstrate actual damage has been caused by that infringement before compensation will be awarded by the courts.
For more information, please contact our data protection team.