A recent Technology and Construction Court decision serves as a reminder that businesses cannot always avoid contractual liability by arguing that the employee responsible lacked authority to enter into agreements.
We look at the recent case of Ion Surety Company SA and another v Shapoorji Pallonji Mideast LLC [2026] and what this means for the principles of actual and apparent authority.
The case arose from a bond for a large construction project in Barking. The claimants, Ion Surety and Ion Insurance (Ion), had supplied a bond for the contractor and had in turn obtained a cross-company indemnity from one of the contractor’s group entities, Shapoorji Pallonji Mideast LLC (SPME).
The indemnity had been negotiated by a broker for SPME and had been signed on behalf of SPME by its employee Robert O’Leary, stated in the signature block to be a “Manager”.
When Ion claimed sums due under the indemnity, SPME argued, among other things, that Mr O’Leary was not a “Manager” and had no actual or apparent authority to sign the indemnity or to bind SPME.
The court held that the indemnity was binding on SPME. It found that Mr O’Leary had actual authority to sign the indemnity on the company’s behalf, having been delegated that authority by the officers of the company through SPME’s updated Memorandum of Association and a subsequent board resolution.
Even if Mr O'Leary had not been granted actual authority through SPME's internal delegation arrangements, SPME was still bound because the indemnity was entered into with SPME’s apparent authority, citing established principles from Freeman & Lockyer v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Ltd [1964] and the more recent case of The Law Debenture Trust Corpn plc v Ukraine [2023].
Internal limits do not necessarily protect you externally
The defendant argued that the signatory lacked authority to bind the company. The court disagreed, finding that it had delegated authority via the appropriate internal procedures. Importantly, however, even if these procedures had not been followed, the signatory still had apparent authority and this was sufficient to bind SPME.
The practical message is that while internal delegation policies are important, they are only part of the picture.
This was not a case where the signatory had conducted the whole business without the knowledge of other company personnel. Throughout the negotiation and transaction, Ion had principally dealt with SPME’s broker, and Mr O’Leary was just one of a number of senior individuals at SPME who had been included in the relevant correspondence.
Where a company allows an employee or officer to negotiate, correspond and execute documents on its behalf, it may later find it difficult to argue that the individual lacked authority.
For parties seeking to challenge a signatory's authority, contemporaneous records and witness evidence can be critical.
In this case, SPME did not call Mr O’Leary, the actual signatory, to give evidence. Nor did it call the two managers who were said to have delegated authority to him. This was undoubtedly very damaging to its case. The judge, Adrian Williamson KC, described SPME's case as "extraordinary" and, in the absence of any witness evidence explaining what had occurred, concluded that he could “properly draw an inference… that there is no or no adequate explanation”.
Where authority is in dispute, parties should be prepared to support their position with clear documentary and witness evidence. A failure to do so may allow the court to draw adverse inferences about what their evidence would have shown.
During the course of proceedings, SPME amended its defence four times. Notably, the argument that Mr O’Leary lacked authority was not raised until 18 months after SPME served its initial defence. The final amendment to the defence was filed in early October 2026, only about three weeks before the trial was due to start.
When Ion updated its Reply to the Defence in light of the amendments, SPME protested that it did not have time to gather evidence to rebut Ion’s points. SPME requested that either trial be adjourned or that Ion be prevented from advancing those arguments at trial.
The judge took the view that SPME could and should have made its points much sooner than it did rather than relying on repeated amendments so close to trial. Understandably, he concluded that any resulting problems with the presentation of its case were of its own making.
The case demonstrates that attempts to introduce entirely new arguments late in the day can undermine a party's credibility and leave insufficient time to gather the evidence needed to support them.
The case provides a useful reminder of the need to be clear about who within an organisation has authority to enter into binding agreements. Businesses should also remember that authority is judged not only by internal procedures, but by how matters appear to the outside world. If a company allows an individual to appear authorised to negotiate and execute agreements on its behalf, it may still be bound by those agreements, even where internal approval processes were not properly followed.
Maintain clear internal delegation and approval procedures;
Record any limits on signing authority and ensure employees understand them;
Ensure counterparties know when board approval or further authorisation is required;
Regularly review who is permitted to enter contracts on behalf of the business.
Verify who at the other party has authority to execute significant agreements;
Request copies of board resolutions or powers of attorney where appropriate;
If there is any doubt, keep your own records showing why you believed authority existed.
For parties engaged in disputes:
If you believe a document has been signed without adequate authority, establish this as early as possible;
Obtain witness statements from all relevant people at your organisation, especially where the case will turn on questions of who knew what and when;
Carefully consider the commercial reality of the situation with a view to settlement – technical defences about execution formalities will struggle if the substance of the deal and resulting benefit is clear.
For more information, please contact our construction team.